Showing posts with label post-socialism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label post-socialism. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

A most brilliant afternoon

Yesterday I had one of my regular meetings with my friend, Romana. We are language partners, meeting regularly to speak English and Czech. Yesterday, she suggested that we go to the Vrtbovská zahrada (garden) in Malá Strana. I hadn't been yet and the day was beautiful so I was happy with her suggestion. We wandered through the baroque gardens - and of course, I didn't have my camera with me - and enjoyed the day. Then, she said that she wanted to take me to her friend Jindřich to see his very special and interesting well. Okay. Sure. I was a bit confused but what the heck. We walked a few blocks to the Pállfyho Palác.

There was a cafe there but more importantly a gathering. The Nonstop čtení 2009 (Nonstop Reading 2009) was taking place. From June 2 to 5, they will read nonstop literature written between 1969 and 1989, or literature of the normalization. It's the 12th year that they do it. The small courtyard in front of the building was strung with rope and plastic-coated articles and other pieces of literature. And there was a small party going on, people milling around, chatting, drinking wine, etc. So, when we arrived we met Jindřich and Romana took me to see the well. I had no idea what to expect. She took me through the building to a little apartment, then down and farther into the building finally to a well. It has been covered over and is dry but it's definitely a well, maybe 20-30 meters deep. She said that there is a legend about the well, that long ago (during the Middle Ages possibly?) 7 nuns were drowned there for having relations with a monk. He was not drowned; his punishment was to watch them being drowned. Typical.

So, after the well, we went back out to join the party and when asked where I'm from I answered, "US" and "Texas." Texas was the right answers. I had my hand kissed and people, okay older men, kept coming up or bringing others over, introducing themselves to me, speaking a little English but primarily Czech, making sure my wine glass was always full... It was also made known that I am trying to speak/undersand Czech so they enjoyed watching me perform. A common request when someone hears that I can "speak Czech" is to "say something, what can you say?" So, I say how I'm a student, doing research and impress them. Oh, and being an anthropologist was of interest also :).

Then, the afternoon turned a bit more surreal. The "boss" of the place - remember, I'm getting my information from my bad Czech and Romana's weak English so - I think his name was Karel - there wasn't a lot of names given just information about when someone was in the US. On that note, another man and I had an interesting conversation about the Czechs in Texas being forced to fight in the Civil War. When he was in the US, he became interested in the Civil War. Anyway, "Karel" asked if we had seen the special place, which I hadn't (????), so he led us inside to a different room and it was the quintessential scholar's living room. Slightly-crooked bookshelves everywhere, full of books, photos fillling any available wall space, oriental carpets on the floor, velvet-covered settee and chairs, piano stuck in the corner...it was a amazing. He told us to sit and then started to chuckle telling me that at one point, in the exact spot where I was sitting, sat Salman Rushdie. Oh, and Prince Charles sat in the spot next to me, apparently not at the same time. On the wall next to me was a photo of the Dalai Lama. Then he pointed out that behind me were pictures of Kurt Vonnegut and John Updike planting trees. Alan Ginsberg. Václav Havel. As my jaw dropped, my eyes got bigger. I was in the most amazing place I had ever been. And Karel so enjoyed showing it all to this young American. After staying at the event for about an hour, I had to leave; I had my Czech lesson. I didn't want to go! So, when I said my farewells, I had a valid excuse, although they said that I was having a Czech lesson with them already! But I'll return. Jindřich is a friend of Romana and her boyfriend and we have promised that I will return to talk with him....about anthropology, culture, society, drugs? It's probably a good thing that I went to my Czech class, I've got a lot to learn!

PS. Czech class was good. At least with Dana my understanding is improving and I was getting the gist of conversations at the reading...I can see the corner and am hurrying to turn it!

Monday, March 23, 2009

Sugarcoating Socialism

I had an interesting conversation yesterday. After church, a group of us went to lunch and one man, let's call him Leo, asked me what I do. So after I explained my research, he boiled it down to a few keywords, healthcare, migration, 21st century…to which I added "and post-socialism." Which led him to question my use of the word "socialism" instead of communism. I explained that we use them essentially as synonyms, although that we know – "we" meaning in academia – that although there is a difference that we are talking about the same time period. To which he asked why we don't just call a spade a spade? And I just said that I use a variety of terms, including post-socialism, -communism, -Soviet, -Cold War, -1989…and that it's really about a time period. He pauses and says "okay, you're an anthropologist…I'm just trying to figure out who would want to sugarcoat this." At this point, I was getting a little offended and said "we do not sugarcoat it." I tried to explain that first, we weren't sugarcoating anything and that other people in fields such as history, economics, political science, sociology, etc use the term post-socialism. That the term is more neutral. That many of our organizations and journals use "socialism" rather than "communism." That in my view, we can all agree that these governments were socialist, especially when they called themselves socialist republics, they were run by the socialist parties, etc. But that not everyone agrees that we can use the term communism because true communism was never met. He agreed that he had heard that argument before but he seemed to want to put it in the same category that I would put comments that the Holocaust never happened or that the 1969 Moon landing took place in a Hollywood backlot. I was basically trying to make the claim that we use a neutral term because we are scientists but he just kept accusing me – and I'm not overreacting because his tone and words indicated this – of belittling the terror and trauma that people went through during the Soviet era (he liked the term post-Soviet era). He also said that by using "socialism" that we are painting the Western socialist with the same brush – to which I countered that it's about context and that any educated person knows (yes, I was getting a little catty here) that we don't mean the same type of socialism when we talk about the former Eastern Bloc, or even China or Cuba, that we do about France or Sweden. But that I understand how that word can be used as a boogeyman, like it has recently in our own Congress while debating the bailouts. I guess what bothered me about this conversation was that I felt that I could not influence him to see my way and if not was it my fault? That at the end of the conversation he seemed to think that what I do is try to erase the bad times…Was I not making my argument strong enough? Or was it him? Oh, and I forgot to mention that this is an American. I believe his wife is Czech. I know that words have power. And we have discussed the use of terminology in our classes. So, maybe this conversation helped me to justify to myself why I lean towards certain terms and not others.